Best News & Current Affairs Blog (2011 & 2012) and Jamaican Blogger of the Year (2011) at The Jamaica Blog Awards.

Portia’s Cabinet? Closet? Wardrobe

The Newly Formed Cabinet

The new Prime Minister, The Most Hon. Portia Simpson Miller, has appointed the largest executive branch in recent history; naming a stunning 19 Ministers and 8 Ministers of State. This is surprising considering Mrs. Simpson Miller, then Opposition Leader, had blasted Bruce Golding for naming an 18 member Cabinet. Even more curious is the reasoning behind the large executive.

According to the Prime Minister, her party is in “succession planning” and therefore many of the young parliamentarians are being made to understudy their more experienced colleagues. Needless to say this excuse has found no favour with me; it is unacceptable for the PNP to undergo succession planning at the expense of taxpayers. That is entirely a party matter and the country should not be made to pick up the tab. Naming a Cabinet is not a cheap undertaking and considering the fiscal constraints of the country, Mrs. Simpson Miller should have been less extravagant. She needed to have been mindful of her own commitment to the Jamaican people that she would not lead a large Cabinet, but rather one that was lean and succinct. This is a clear violation of that promise. It curiously goes against the idea of honouring and respecting the people, something we’ve heard the new Prime Minister speak a lot about.

Now the actual portfolio assignments. I’ve taken serious issue with a few appointments.

Roger Clarke

Firstly, the appointment of AJ Nicholson as Foreign Minister and Roger Clarke as Agriculture Minister is unacceptable. The PNP needs to demonstrate, by action, it’s commitment to youth and renewal. The very reasons I objected to Mike Henry and Pearnel Charles being in the former administration’s Cabinet stands here. These political fossils must relinquish their vice like grip on our political system. Senator Nicholson has had his day, it is time for him to step aside. Lord knows Roger Clarke can retire now. The honourable thing to do would have been to decline the post of Minister, but I suppose that’s asking too much of a politicians who believe they have some right to be in office for life.

Lisa Hanna

Secondly, there is a Ministry of Youth & Culture. This again is wasteful spending. While I laud the Prime Minister for appointing Lisa Hanna a full Minister, the Ministry itself is imprudent. Youth and Culture are not portfolios that need to be alone. The two could have been properly affixed to Education or Information; thus removing and cutting back on the need for 19 Ministers. Sandrea Falconer, the current Information Minister, need only be a Senator. Lisa Hanna could have handled Information, Youth & Culture just fine. What this tells me is that the Prime Minister wasn’t appointing a Cabinet being mindful of our financial constraints, but rather, she was appointing one to reward every Tom, Dick, Harry and Jane who helped her win the election. This is grossly unacceptable. The size of the Government should reflect the current financial situation of the country.

The Ministry of Local Government & Community Development is another act of extravagance and waste. Mrs. Simpson Miller could have assumed this portfolio under the Office of the Prime Minister and assigned one of the 4 Minister without portfolios to it. That immediately cuts one more Cabinet post, taking the Cabinet down to 17. The super Ministry of Water, Lands, Environment and Climate Change is also curious. Lands could have been attached to Agriculture, Environment attached to Health; Water placed with Housing, considering there is a Junior Minister for Housing, and Climate Change placed in the OPM. This takes the Cabinet down to 16 Ministers, a far more tolerable number.

Peter Bunting

That said, there are positives. Peter Bunting as National Security Minister is a wise move. Bunting was particularly vocal during the shameful Manatt/Dudus affair. The Rev. Ronnie Thwaites is Education Minister, I’ve always admired Deacon Thwaites for his forceful and outspoken attitude in the House of Representatives. He has been a good Member of Parliament and I anticipate he will take that attitude to Education. Dr. Phillips as Finance Minister is also commendable. I anticipate that Dr. Phillips will perform well in his new capacity, being open and honest about the state of the Jamaican economy. I am also happy Dr. Omar Davies is no where near the Finance Ministry, but instead has been given Transport, Works and Housing. He can continue his crusade against the alleged mismanagement of JDIP. Arnaldo Brown as Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, Damion Crawford as Deputy Minister of Tourism. These are progressive and commendable steps.

This is a rather large and extravagant Cabinet. It is my considered opinion that it could do well with some trimming. The proof will be in the performance, we wait to see how that goes.

[See full list of Cabinet Ministers Here]


6 responses

  1. Great blog as always! I disagree with your overly enthusiastic declaration re Crawford. While I think he should have a post, it should not be Tourism and Entertainment because he owns a tourism related company. That looks like a conflict of interest… we shall not accept even a hint of such. I can’t accept that!

    January 6, 2012 at 11:17 pm

  2. Mattdk

    A lot of shuffling could have taken place. I can’t remember what they were, it’s minutes to 3 in the morning. What I can remember is that Paulwell and Clarke should never have been included. Julian Robinson could have effectively replaced Paulwell, or at least be put in charge of a Government Ministry to deal with the introduction/growth of the ICT sector.

    January 7, 2012 at 2:50 am

  3. DK

    Actually, I agree for the most part, but I have to disagree with where you said ” The super Ministry of Water, Lands, Environment and Climate Change is also curious. Lands could have been attached to Agriculture, Environment attached to Health; Water placed with Housing, considering there is a Junior Minister for Housing, and Climate Change placed in the OPM. ”

    As someone who works IN the environment field, I think this was a fairly good move, as all of these sectors are more closely related than persons realise, and also that environment is SIGNIFICANTLY more important to our economy in the long run than people know. Climate Change and environment definitely belong together, the two cannot be more related. Joining environment with health has been done in the past, and it was almost ignored. Putting agriculture with lands would actually be a conflict of interest, as monoculture (used heavily in agriculture) reduces our biodiversity (environment again). Water could be with housing, but do you know how much of our available ground water is too contaminated to be used? This is definitely due to the environment being neglected.

    The rest of your criticisms (and praises) I agree with, but I thought I’d share my views on this one…

    January 7, 2012 at 12:41 pm

    • Thanks for the perspective 🙂 I appreciate it. I suppose I was speaking without that technical knowledge. Glad you liked the other points though.

      January 7, 2012 at 1:08 pm

  4. Good article tend to agree with it for the most part. Peter Phillips should have gotten a financial guru with him at finance,he is a good manager but I am not sure he can manage the finance portfolio on his own. I think behind the scenes Dr. Davies will be the finance minister, it is already evident because he is still speaking on finance related issues even though he is no longer has finance. I agree with one of the comments about Damion, he has a tourism related company so he must be careful.

    January 7, 2012 at 1:02 pm

    • Well, I mean anybody has to be better than Davies, right? Hahaha. Thanks for your comments; glad you liked the post.

      January 7, 2012 at 1:10 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s